New publication: Reconciling the potentially irreconcilable? Genotypic and phenotypic amoxicillin-clavulanate resistance in Escherichia coli. Philip Fowler, 30th March 202022nd August 2020 0 shares Clinical microbiology often assumes a sample is resistant or susceptible. Making such a classification relies on applying a threshold (usually called a cutoff) to quantitative data, such as minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs). If the MICs are strongly bimodal, then this is trivial and reproducibility is guaranteed. If the MICs are unimodal, then one is left with the unsatisfactory situation whereby the clinical test does not appear to be reproducible since natural variation can cause individual results to “flip-flop” over the cutoff. Tim Davies, who led this work (open access), shows that whilst amoxicillin, a beta-lactam antibiotic, has a bimodal MIC distribution, when taken with the beta-lactamase inhibitor clavulanate in the combined therapy co-amoxiclav, the MIC distribution becomes unimodal with all the attendant problems of a lack of reproducibility. This is further complicated by the US and European bodies (CLSI and EUCAST) adopting incompatible testing approaches. The original aim of this work was the test how well knowing the genetics of an E.coli infection could be used to predict its susceptibility to standard treatments, like co-amoxiclav. Simple presence/absence of beta-lactamase genes is not sufficient; instead the predictive model has to include knowledge of promoter mutations and copy number. Even with these improvements, the above reproducibilty problem ensures there is an upper threshold to the sensitivity/specificity possible. In other words, translating genetics into clinical microbiology for E.coli is going to be a whole lot harder than it was for M. tuberculosis! Share this:Twitter Related antimicrobial resistance clinical microbiology publication research
antimicrobial resistance Genetics and Tuberculosis: A Case of New Meets Old 12th July 2019 I was very pleased to be invited to contribute to this “Voices” article organised by… Share this:Twitter Read More
publication New Publication: Proteins Alter the Stiffness of Membranes 23rd September 201629th September 2018 Although there have been many studies of proteins whose primary function is to ‘sculpt’ the… Share this:Twitter Read More
New publication: determining novel mechanisms of bedaquiline resistance 30th March 20235th April 2023 A new paper with Lindsay Sonnenkalb as first-author has just been published in The Lancet… Share this:Twitter Read More